Your customers aren’t making impulse purchases. Stop marketing to them like they are.
Are you selling Snickers Bars?
Because if you are, YouTube Shorts might be a brilliant marketing strategy.
Somebody’s hungry. They see chocolate, caramel, peanuts. They want a Snickers. They buy a Snickers. Everybody’s happy.
Nobody checks the chocolatier’s credentials.
Nobody requests references from the peanuts.
Nobody spends three weeks comparing candy bars before making a decision they’ll have to live with for the next twenty years.
Now imagine you’re a criminal defense attorney. Or a roofing contractor. Or somebody installing hardwood floors in a 120-year-old house.
Or anything more consequential than a candy bar.
If you’re selling something that requires trust, expertise, and a substantial financial commitment, why are you measuring success by how many strangers watched fifteen seconds of video?
I produce podcasts and YouTube content for lawyers, contractors, and nonprofits. I’ve spent a lot of time watching what happens after people click Play.
And I’ve got some numbers that make the Shorts obsession look pretty ridiculous.
Congratulations. You Got 100,000 Views. Did Anybody Give a Shit?
Across several YouTube channels I manage, I examined subscriber acquisition representing approximately 7,500 subscribers.
Shorts generated more total views than long-form videos.
Yet less than 1% of those subscribers came from Shorts.
And then there’s this delightful little collection of actual video results:
| Video | Views | New Subscribers | Subscribers per 1,000 Views |
|---|---|---|---|
| Short | 10,000 | 0 | 0 |
| Long-form | 75,000 | 500 | 6.7 |
| Long-form | 175,000 | 6,000 | 34.3 |
The 175,000-view long-form video was a home run. Six thousand new subscribers.
The 75,000-view video? Still a solid double. Five hundred subscribers.
The Short delivered 10,000 views and precisely zero subscribers.
Ten thousand people showed up. Nobody wanted to stick around.
These are individual examples from my channels, not a controlled experiment. Other creators may get very different results. I’m not running their channels. I’m running mine.
Let’s Talk About What You’re Actually Selling
A $2 candy bar, a $7,000 floor, and criminal defense representation have very different customers.
| The Purchase | What’s Going Through Their Head | What Useful Content Can Do |
|---|---|---|
| Snickers Bar | That looks good. | Get noticed. |
| $$$ Hardwood Refinishing | Will this contractor screw up my house? | Demonstrate methods and workmanship. |
| $$$$ Roof | Will this roof protect my house? | Explain materials and installation. |
| $?$?$ Criminal Defense | Can I trust this person with my future? | Demonstrate legal knowledge and judgment. |
Would You Hire a Criminal Defense Attorney Based on a Fifteen-Second Video?
Imagine you’re facing criminal charges in New Jersey. You’re scared. You’ve got questions. You need somebody who understands what happens in court.
One attorney has a Short with dramatic music, giant captions, and three things you MUST KNOW if you’ve been arrested.
Another has a substantial conversation with an experienced legal professional about an issue relevant to your situation.
You can hear the attorney explain the law, ask questions, respond to disagreement, and work through complicated issues.
Which one gives you more information about the lawyer?
That’s why I enjoy producing the Mighty MERP Podcast with New Jersey criminal defense attorney Melissa Rosenblum.
Melissa is a working trial attorney. Her conversations with other legal professionals provide opportunities to demonstrate what she knows without interrupting somebody’s scrolling session to yell legal tips at them.
For a lawyer, the expertise is the product. Why hide it behind fifteen seconds of entertainment?
Hardwood Refinishing: A Short Can Show It. A Conversation Can Explain It.
I’ve worked with hardwood flooring contractors discussing renovations in historic New Jersey homes.
A beautiful before-and-after video is terrific. People like beautiful floors. I like beautiful floors.
But a homeowner spending thousands of dollars might want answers to questions like these:
- Solid or engineered hardwood? Which is appropriate for the house?
- What’s under the existing floor? Does the subfloor need attention?
- What about moisture? How will conditions affect the installation?
- How is the floor installed? Which methods make sense for the project?
- Can it be refinished? What should the homeowner expect years from now?
That’s a conversation with somebody who knows what they’re doing.
And if I’m a homeowner deciding which contractor gets my money, I’d appreciate hearing those answers before anybody starts ripping up my house.
105 Views. Almost 60 Hours of Attention. Somebody Call the Algorithm Police.
I took existing podcast recordings and assembled three standalone YouTube compilations. No new interviews. No new recording sessions. Just previously recorded conversations edited into long videos.
And I mean long videos.
| Compilation | Length | Engaged Views | Average Duration | Watch Hours |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mighty MERP | 8h 39m | 29 | 39m | 18.85 |
| NJ Criminal Podcast | 8h 30m | 36 | 35m 13s | 21.1 |
| Bridgeton Beacon | 6h 40m | 40 | 29m 06s | 19.4 |
| Total | 23h 49m | 105 | About 33m 55s | 59.35 |
The Mighty MERP compilation averaged 39 minutes of viewing per engaged view. The NJ Criminal Podcast compilation averaged more than 35 minutes.
And Bridgeton Beacon, featuring South Jersey stories and history, averaged approximately 29 minutes.
Imagine telling somebody their video was a failure because it got 29 engaged views, while overlooking almost nineteen hours of accumulated watch time.
That doesn’t prove anybody became a client or donor. But it does tell me people were willing to spend serious time with the material.
Since When Is Fifteen Minutes of Somebody’s Attention a Failure?
I’ve heard people worry about an hour-long podcast because its average viewer watches only twelve or fifteen minutes.
Only?
Try stopping somebody on the sidewalk and explaining New Jersey criminal procedure for fifteen minutes.
See how that goes.
People listen during commutes, workouts, and household chores. They get interrupted. Sometimes they return. Sometimes they don’t.
But if somebody voluntarily spends fifteen minutes listening to a contractor explain a flooring installation, that contractor has had fifteen minutes to demonstrate expertise without delivering a sales pitch.
And Here’s the Part I Really Like: You Only Had to Record It Once
A single hour-long conversation can produce an extraordinary amount of material.
Take the hardwood flooring discussion. The contractor sits down once and talks about work they already know.
- Full-length YouTube video: The complete conversation.
- Audio podcast: For people who prefer listening.
- Transcript: The discussion preserved in searchable text.
- Focused articles: Solid versus engineered floors, subfloors, moisture, maintenance.
- Short clips: Individual answers and interesting moments.
- Future compilations: Related material from multiple conversations.
One recording session. Multiple outputs.
And the contractor gets back to installing floors instead of spending Tuesday afternoon inventing something to say to Instagram.
Yes, I produce Shorts. I cut clips. But the long-form recording is where I get the substance that makes those clips worth producing.
And Please, Stop Asking Me About YouTube Monetization
Lawyers ask me about YouTube monetization.
I find this hilarious.
You’re a criminal defense attorney. Your business is representing people charged with crimes. Why are you worried about how much YouTube might pay you for advertising?
Same goes for the contractor selling a $15,000 roof.
YouTube isn’t your customer. The person who needs a lawyer is.
Wouldn’t you rather your video helped somebody decide to call you about the work you actually do?
There’s an entirely separate discussion about Shorts monetization economics. But for businesses selling expensive services, it’s a ridiculous distraction from the actual business.
Five Questions Before You Make Another Short
- Who’s watching? Could these people realistically need your services?
- Are they sticking around? Do they subscribe or watch more?
- What are they learning? Does the content demonstrate expertise?
- Is it producing inquiries? Anything meaningful beyond the view counter?
- Could the same time create something substantial? An interview, demonstration, or useful explanation?
If your Shorts are producing customers, great. You’ve got evidence they’re working.
But if the only number moving is the view counter, maybe you’re entertaining strangers instead of marketing a business.
So, Are You Selling Snickers Bars?
A Snickers Bar doesn’t have to explain its qualifications. A criminal defense attorney does.
A candy bar doesn’t need to demonstrate workmanship. A flooring contractor does.
I’ve seen long-form videos generate hundreds and thousands of subscribers. I’ve also seen Shorts generate thousands of views without attracting a single new subscriber.
I’m interested in the people who want to hear more, especially when they’re the people who might actually need what the business sells.
Views don’t hire you. People do.
If you’re selling something more expensive than a Snickers Bar, maybe it’s time to fuck Shorts.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are YouTube Shorts effective for lawyers?
They can introduce an attorney to new viewers, but views don’t establish whether those people need legal services. Longer conversations give prospective clients more opportunity to hear the attorney explain legal issues and demonstrate professional knowledge.
Do Shorts generate subscribers?
Yes, but results vary. In my sample of approximately 7,500 subscribers across several managed channels, fewer than 1% were attributed to Shorts, despite Shorts generating more total views.
Is long-form video better for contractors?
It can be useful when homeowners need to understand materials, methods, costs, and workmanship before committing to an expensive project. A contractor can explain those decisions in detail rather than relying entirely on finished-project footage.
How should professional service businesses measure YouTube success?
Look beyond views. Evaluate subscriber acquisition, watch time, relevant website visits, inquiries, and actual customers. A million views from people who will never hire you may be less commercially useful than a smaller audience interested in your services.
Should businesses stop producing Shorts entirely?
Not if they’re producing worthwhile results. Clips can introduce viewers to longer content. But if Shorts consume significant time without producing subscribers, inquiries, or other relevant outcomes, reconsider the investment.
Why use podcasts for professional service marketing?
A podcast lets professionals explain what they know. One recording can supply a long-form video, audio episode, transcript, articles, clips, and future compilations without requiring a separate recording session for each format.
About the Author
Tom Ritter produces podcasts and YouTube content for lawyers, contractors, and nonprofits, including Mighty MERP, the NJ Criminal Podcast, and Bridgeton Beacon.
ARTICLES
Better Intel And
Smarter Marketing
Would You Rather Get 105 YouTube Views or 100,000 YouTube Shorts Views?
Your customers aren’t making impulse purchases. Stop marketing to…
Melissa Rosenblum’s Marketing Is Preposterously Efficient. That’s the Genius of It.
How a busy New Jersey criminal trial attorney turns…
Best Extended Stay Hotel in Rowland, NC, and the StudioRes Opportunity
How an independently operated hotel along I-95 can turn…
